JUDGMENTS FOR THE MONTH OF MAY, 2014

 

DATED

CASE NO.

TITLE

SUBJECT

JUDGMENT DELIVERED BY

8TH

CRL.A.1362/2011 & CRL.M.B.Nos. 2442/2013, 669/2013 & 1047/2013

AKIL & OTHERS

VERUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

1ST

CRL.A. 545/2011 & CRL.M.B.No. 209/2014

 

INDER DEV YADAV AND ORS.

VERSUS

STATE

NDPS ACT

S.P.GARG,J

1ST

CRL.A. 673/1999

 

OM PRAKASH & ORS.

VERSUS

STATE

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

KAILASH GAMBHIR,J

SUNITA GUPTA,J

 

1ST

FAO No. 85/2013

 

SCHINDLER INDIA PVT. LTD.

VERSUS

PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT

EMPLOYEE’S COMPENSATION ACT

 

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

1ST

WP(C) No. 3376/2013

 

JOBY P VARGHESE AND ANR

VERSUS

UNION OF INDIA AND ORS             

Essential Services Maintenance Act, 1968

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

1ST

FAO No. 392/2013

 

MAHESH CHAND SHARMA    

VERSUS

ARORA FINANCE CO. 

ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 1996

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

1ST

FAO No. 85/2013

 

SCHINDLER INDIA PVT. LTD.

VERSUS

PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT & ORS.

Employee’s Compensation Act, 1923

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

1ST

FAO No. 402/2012

 

SUNITA

VERSUS

UNION OF INDIA

RAILWAY CLAIMS TRIBUNAL ACT, 1987

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

2ND

CRL.M.C. 1101/2013

 

ATELIER FASHION FLASH PVT. LTD

VERSUS

PROVIDENT FUND INSPECTOR

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

VED PRAKASH VAISH,J

2ND

CRL.REV.P. 51/2005

 

C.B.I. 

VERSUS

R.C.BHARGAVA & ANR.        

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

VEENA BIRBAL,J

2ND

CRL.A.323/2000

 

GOBIND MISHRA

VERSUS

STATE N.C.T. OF DELHI      

INDIAN PENAL CODE

MUKTA GUPTA,J

 

2ND

CRL.A. 1322/2012 & CRL.M.B.No. 1594/2013

 

RAHUL MAKKAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

2ND

CRL. M.C. No.148/2012

 

SOMESH SHOKEEN

VERSUS

STATE GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI      

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

 

VED PRAKASH VAISH,J

2ND

CRL.M.C. No. 2074/2014

 

SURESH CHAND DAHIYA

VERSUS

STATE

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

VED PRAKASH VAISH,J

2ND

LPA 345/2014

 

SHRI BIRENDER SINGH

VERSUS

UOI

ADMISSION MATTER

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

2ND

FAO(OS) 72/2014, CM No.4467/2014

FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA

VERSUS

SHIVA RICE MILLS & ANR

Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

2ND

CRL.A.323/2000

 

GOBIND MISHRA       

VERSUS

STATE N.C.T. OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

MUKTA GUPTA,J

2ND

W.P.(C) 5492/2013

 

HARJEET SHARMA & ORS

VERSUS

UNION OF INDIA & ORS

SERVICE MATTER

GITA MITTAL,J

DEEPA SHARMA,J

2ND

LPA 348/2014 & CM No.7787/2014

MEGH SINGH

VERSUS

GOVT OF NCT DELHI 

COMPENSATION MATTER

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

 

2ND

WP(C) No.2757/2014 and CM No.5720/2014

SI (M) ARUN KUMAR PODDAR

VERSUS

UOI

SERVICE MATTER

REVA KHETRAPAL,J

PRATIBHA RANI,J

2ND

CRL. M.C. No.148/2012

SOMESH SHOKEEN

VERSUS

STATE GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI      

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

VED PRAKASH VAISH

2ND

CRL.M.C. No. 2074/2014

 

SURESH CHAND DAHIYA      

VERSUS

STATE

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

 

VED PRAKASH VAISH

5TH

CRL.A. 1388/2012 & Crl.M.A.No.7071/2014

 

DHARMENDER

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

 

S.P.GARG

5TH

FAO No.130/2014

 

DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION

VERSUS

GIAN CHAND  

EMPLOYEE’S  COMPENSATION ACT, 1923

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

5TH

FAO No. 128/2014 and FAO 129/2014

 

JAGDAMBA IMPEX     

VERSUS

TRISTAR PRODUCTS PRIVATE LTD.       

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

5TH

CRL.A. 1305/2013

 

MUKESH @ MUKKA

VERSUS

STATE (NCT OF DELHI)

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

5TH

FAO No.132/2014

 

NORTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATION

VERSUS

ASHOK KUMAR GUPTA         

ARBITRATION & CONCILIATION ACT

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

5TH

CRL.REV.P. 45/2014

 

WASIF

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

VEENA BIRBAL,J

5TH

CRL.M.C. No.535/2014

 

ARSHI IRSHAD

VERSUS

STATE GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

VED PRAKASH VAISH,J

5TH

MAC.APP.185/2013

 

BIMLA DEVI & ANR.

VERSUS

MOHAN SINGH & ORS.

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

 

SURESH KAIT,J

5TH

CRL.A. 1388/2012 & Crl.M.A.No.7071/2014

DHARMENDER 

VERSUS

STATE NCT OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

5TH

FAO No.130/2014

 

 

DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION

VERSUS

GIAN CHAND

Employee’s  Compensation Act, 1923

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

5TH

W.P.(C) 2789/2014, CAV.398/2014 & C.M. NOS. 5794/2014 & 5795/2014

J.S. ARORA AND ORS

VERSUS

STATE BANK OF HYDERABAD AND ORS.

RECOVERY OF DEBTS DUE TO BANKS AND FINANCIAL

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

VIBHU BAKHRU,J

 

5TH

FAO No. 128/2014 & CM Nos. 7778-79/2014

 

JAGDAMBA IMPEX

VERSUS

TRISTAR PRODUCTS PRIVATE LTD.       

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

5TH

FAO(OS) 201/2014.

 

MD IFTEKHAR

VERSUS

KARIM HOTELS PVT LTD.

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

 

5TH

CRL.A. 1305/2013

 

MUKESH @ MUKKA

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

5TH

MAC.APP. 371/2014

 

NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD.      

VERSUS

RIYASAT KHAN & ORS.        

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

5TH

FAO No. 443/2011

 

NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD.   

VERSUS

DEV RAJ JOSHI

COMPENSATION MATTER

VALMIKI J.MEHTA

5TH

FAO No.132/2014

 

NORTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATION 

VERSUS

ASHOK KUMAR GUPTA

Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

5TH

MAC.APP.261/2013

 

UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD

VERSUS

TEJPAL SINGH & ORS.         

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT

5TH

FAO No.467/2013

 

UNION OF INDIA

VERSUS

GAUTAM ANAND

Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987

VALMIKI J.MEHTA

6TH

CRL.A. 958/2012 & CRL.M.B.No. 706/2014

 

BABLOO @ UMESH KUMAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

 

6TH

CRL.A. 734/2012 & CRL.M.B.No. 509/2014

 

RAVI AZAD

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG

 

6TH

CRL.A. 514/2003

 

SHANKAR      

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

6TH

CRL.A. 86/2000

 

VINAY KUMAR TYAGI

VERSUS

STATE OF DELHI      

INDIAN PENAL CODE

MUKTA GUPTA,J

6TH

FAO(OS) 357/2013 & CM No.11998/2013 (for stay)

ANITA KUMARI GUPTA

VERSUS

LATE MR VED BHUSHAN

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

 

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

6TH

CRL.A. 958/2012 & CRL.M.B.No. 706/2014

BABLOO @ UMESH KUMAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

6TH

ITA 29/2014

CM APPL.1598-1600/2014

 

CHEIL INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED

VERSUS

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX

Income Tax Act, 1961

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

VIBHU BAKHRU,J

6TH

ITA 206/2014

 

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX

VERSUS

KUSUM GUPTA         

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

VIBHU BAKHRU,J

6TH

W.P.(C) 6390/2012

 

KAMPURI       

VERSUS

BSES RAJDHANI POWER LTD & ANR.

SERVICE MATTER

RAJIV SHAKDHER

6TH

ITA 199/2014

 

PAWAN KUMAR AGGARWAL

VERSUS

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX             

INOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT

VIBHU BAKHRU,J

 

6TH

CRL.A. 734/2012 & CRL.M.B.No. 509/2014

RAVI AZAD

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

6TH

CRL.A. 514/2003

 

SHANKAR      

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

7TH

CRL. APPEAL NO.760/2002 & CRL. M.A. NO.2542/2002

 

RAJBIR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

7TH

CRL.A.573/2012 & CRL.M.B.No. 392/2014

 

RAKESH KUMAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

7TH

CS(OS) 1112/1998

 

RELIANCE INDUSTRIES LTD.

VERSUS

VIJAY CABLE INDUSTRIES & ORS

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

7TH

Test Cas No.42 of 2006

 

ALKA PURI     

VERSUS

STATE

Court Fee Act, 1870

V.K. SHALI,J

7TH

CRL. APPEAL NO.760/2002 & CRL. M.A. NO.2542/2002

 

RAJBIR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

7TH

CRL.A.573/2012 & CRL.M.B.No. 392/2014

RAKESH KUMAR

VERSUS

THE STATE & ANR.   

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

7TH

CS(OS) 1112/1998

 

RELIANCE INDUSTRIES LTD

VERSUS

VIJAY CABLE INDUSTRIES & ORS

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

7TH

RSA 223/2013

 

SOHAN PAL   

VERSUS

UMASHANKAR & ANR.

Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958

VALMIKI J.MEHTA

8TH

CRL.M.C. No.535/2014

 

ARSHI IRSHAD

VERSUS

STATE

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

VED PRAKASH VAISH,J

8TH

CRL.A. 645/2002

 

PUSHPINDERA

VERSUS

STATE OF NCT OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR

8TH

CRL.A. 400/2011 & Crl.M.B. 64/2014

RAM CHARAN

VERSUS

STATE NCT OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

MUKTA GUPTA,J

8TH

CRL.A. 645/2002

 

PUSHPINDERA

VERSUS

STATE OF NCT OF DELHI    

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

8TH

CRL.A. 400/2011 & Crl.M.B. 64/2014

RAM CHARAN 

VERSUS

STATE NCT OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

MUKTA GUPTA,J

9TH

CRL.A. 300/2012

 

DEEPAK        

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

 

9TH

CRL.A.No. 864/2012

 

MOHD. JAFAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

9TH

CRL.A. 300/2012

 

DEEPAK

VERSUS

STATE (GOVT. OF NCT) OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

 

S.P.GARG,J

9TH

FAO (OS)219/2014

 

GESTURE HOTELS AND FOOD

PVT. LIMITED

VERSUS

THE NEW DELHI MUNCIPAL COUNCIL       

SUIT FOR SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

 

9TH

W.P. (C) 2310/2012

CM APPL.4946 & 17545/2012

INDIAN OLYMPIC ASSOCIATION

VERSUS

UNION OF INDIA

SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

NAJMI WAZIRI,J

9TH

CRL.A. 378/2003

 

JAI NARAIN MALIK

VERSUS

STATE GOVT. OF N.C.T. OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

 

INDERMEET KAUR,J

9TH

CRL.A.No. 864/2012

 

MOHD. JAFAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

9TH

FAO(OS) 210/2014

 

SURENDRA PAL SINGH

VERSUS

RAVINDRA PAL SINGH

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW

12TH

CRL.A. 477/2003

 

KANTA PRASAD        

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

12TH

CRL.A. 813/2000

 

LALITA

VERSUS

STATE

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

KAILASH GAMBHIR,J

SUNITA GUPTA,J

12TH

CRL.A. 455/1998

 

MEHBOOB KHAN @ BABU

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

KAILASH GAMBHIR,J

SUNITA GUPTA,J

12TH

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 399/2014

MOHD. ABID

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G.P. MITTAL,J

 

13TH

CRL. APPEAL NO. 83/2014

 

DILBAGH SINGH

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

 

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G. P. MITTAL,J

13TH

Crl. Appeal No. 100/2014

 

MUNNA PANDIT

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G. P. MITTAL,J

13TH

MAC.APP. 40/2012

 

ANGAD KUMAR         

VERSUS

GOPAL BAHADUR & ORS.

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

13TH

MAC.APP. No.504 /2010

 

ANITA GUPTA

VERSUS

KAMLESH

MOTOR ACCIDENT  CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

13TH

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 480/1999

BALWAN SINGH AND ORS.   

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

 

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G.P. MITTAL,J

13TH

Crl. Appeal No. 83/2014

 

DILBAGH SINGH

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G. P. MITTAL,J

 

13TH

Crl. Appeal No. 100/2014

 

MUNNA PANDIT

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G. P. MITTAL,J

13TH

MAC.APP. No.366 /2010

 

ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.     

VERSUS

ANITA GUPTA & ORS.

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT

13TH

CRL.A. 172/2012

 

Pradeep        

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

MUKTA GUPTA,J

13TH

FAO(OS) 579/2013 & CM No.20049/2013 (for stay)

SANTOSH ARORA & ORS      

VERSUS

M.L. ARORA   

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

13TH

CRL. A. 282/1998

 

SAT PARKASH YADAV

VERSUS

STATE (GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI)   

INDIAN PENAL CODE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G.P. MITTAL,J

 

15TH

CRL.A. 158/2011

 

INDERJEET

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

15TH

MAC.APP. No.778/2012

 

LAL CHAND

VERSUS

PREM AND ORS        

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT

15TH

MAC.APP.434/2012

ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.

VERSUS

KAMLA & ORS

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

15TH

CRL.A.188/2006

 

PARVEZ alias BABLU CHIKNA

VERSUS

STATE

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

15TH

MAC.APP. 628/2011

 

RADHA NIGAM

VERSUS

MANAS BANSAL & ORS

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

16TH

CRL.A. 975/2011

 

JAGMOHAN @ JAGGA

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

16TH

CRL.A.26/2006

 

PANKAJ alias PRAVEEN

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

16TH

MAC.APP. 840/2013

 

SHRIRAM GENERAL INSURANCE CO.

VERSUS

SEEMA & ORS

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

16TH

CRL.A. 200/2006

 

STATE

VERSUS

S.P.TYAGI & ORS.    

PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT

INDERMEET KAUR,J

16TH

MAC.APP.863/2013

 

SUNITA RANA

VERSUS

HITESH KUMAR DHEER & ORS. 

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

16TH

CS(OS) 669/2011

 

TANU GOEL & ANR

VERSUS

GIRISH CHOPRA & ORS

SUIT FOR SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

16TH

CS(OS) 2414/2011

 

TEKLA CORPORATION & ANR

VERSUS

SURVO GHOSH & ANR

SUIT FOR PERMANENT INJUNCTION

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

16TH

MAC.APP. 456/2014

 

VIBHA SINGH & ORS.

VERSUS

TULSI LAL & ORS     

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

16TH

CRL.A. 304/2000

 

VINOD KUMAR ARORA

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

VEENA BIRBAL,J

19TH

CRL.A. 151/2012 & CRL.M.B. 1626/2013

GAURAV

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

20TH

FAO(OS) 61/2014

 

ANITA KAUR

VERSUS

UNIVERSAL WEATHER AND AVIATION INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED & ANR

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

 

20TH

CS(OS) 160/2013

 

HOLLAND COMPANY LP & ANR        

VERSUS

S.P. INDUSTRIES     

SUIT FOR PERMANENT INJUNCTION

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

20TH

FAO(OS) 233/2014, CM No.8270/2014

RAJEEV KUMAR & ANR

VERSUS

MICROSOFT CORPORATION & ANR

SUIT FOR PERMANENT INJUNCTION

CHIEF JUSTICE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J