JUDGMENTS FOR THE MONTH OF APRIL, 2014

 

DATED

CASE NO.

TITLE

SUBJECT

JUDGMENT DELIVERED BY

1ST

CO. APPL. NO.256/2013

DINESH MITTAL

VERSUS

TRIVENI INFRASTRUCTURE

DEVELOPMENT COMPANY LTD

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

R.V.EASWAR,J

1ST

TR.P (C)No. 47/2013  & CM No.8414/2013

MOHD. SHER NABI CHAMAN

VERSUS

DDA

CODE OF CIVIL  PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

1ST

CRL.A.867/2012 & CRL.M.B.No. 453/2014

NARESH

VERSUS

STATE OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

1ST

MAC.A.322/2007

 

NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD

VERSUS

POONAM AND ORS.

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

1ST

MAC.APP. 1203/2012 & CM.No. 19408/2012

NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD

VERSUS

HARISH CHANDER BHATT

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

1ST

MAC.APP. 1227/2012

 

NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO LTD

VERSUS

SHAMIM FATIMA & ORS

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

1ST

FAO 184/2012 & CM NO. 7702/2012

NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD

VERSUS

VIRENDER SINGH & ANR

EMPLOYEE’S COMPENSATION ACT, 1923

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

1ST

CRL.A. 121/2010

 

RAHUL

VERSUS

STATE OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

V.K. JAIN,J

1ST

CRL.A. 251/2006

 

RAVINDER RAM CHANDER BANSHI

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

1ST

CRL.A.205/2011

 

SHAMIULLAH SHEIKH @ SAM @ JEEDAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

 

1ST

CRL.A. 1357/2011

 

SURAJ

VERSUS

NCT OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

1ST

MAC.APP. 330/2007

 

THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE

VERSUS

RAVINDER KUMAR AND ORS.

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

1ST

MAC.APP. 334/2007

 

THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE

VERSUS

ROOP RAM AND ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

1ST

MAC.APP. 249/2011

 

UNITED INDIA INSURANCE

VERSUS

RAMO DEVI & ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

1ST

FAO No.71/2012 and C.M. Nos.17081/2010 (stay) &2039/2013 (stay)

PARMINDER SINGH

VERSUS

VIRENDER PAL SINGH JOLLY

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

 

1ST

ITA 539/2012

 

CIT

VERSUS

OM PRAKASH ARORA

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

2nd

CRL.A.694/1999

 

ABDUL RASHEED

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

KAILASH GAMBHIR,J

SUNITA GUPTA,J

2ND

RSA No. 95/2014 & CM NO. 6100/2014

HAJI ABDUL MATEEN

VERSUS

SHEIKH HAJI FIROZUDDIN

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

2ND

CRL.A. 464/1999

 

JITENDER SINGH

VERSUS

STATE OF DELHI

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

KAILASH GAMBHIR,J

SUNITA GUPTA,J

2ND

MAC.APP. 797/2013

 

M D PANBAS

VERSUS

NEELAM & ORS

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

2ND

MAC.APP. 782/2013

 

M D, PANBAS

VERSUS

RESHMA & ORS

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

2ND

RSA No. 114/2013

 

MINAKSHI ARORA

VERSUS

UMESH KUMAR BATRA

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

2ND

MAC.APP. 390/2013 & CM No. 4095/2014

NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD

VERSUS

PRAVEEN KUMAR AGGARWAL

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

SURESH KAIT,J

2ND

CRL. A.399 of 2013

 

PAWAN

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

V.K. JAIN,J

2ND

CRL.A. 133/2014

RAHUL JAIN @ SONU

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

2ND

MAC.APP. 758/2012

 

RAJBIR SINGH

VERSUS

NATIONAL INS CO LTD

MOTOR ACCIDENT  CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

2ND

MAC.APP. 761/2012

 

RAKESH

VERSUS

NATIONAL INS CO LTD AND ORS

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

2ND

RSA No. 96/2014

 

RAM CHANDER & ANR.         

VERSUS

KRISHAN KUMAR SHARMA

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

2ND

W.P.(CRL) 448/2014

 

RAVI

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G.P. MITTAL,J

 

2ND

CRL.A. 1356/2012

 

SAHIL

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

2ND

CRL.A. 103/2006

SONU @ ATTEY

VERSUS

STATE NCT OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

2ND

FAO No.474/2012

SURAI BESRA

VERSUS

UOI

RAILWAY CLAIMS TRIBUNAL ACT, 1987

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

2nd

MAT.APP.(F.C.) 40/2014

 

JAGDISH       

Versus

MONIKA

CONDONATION OF DELAY

REVA KHETRAPAL,J

PRATIBHA RANI,J

 

3RD

CRL.A. 1242/2010

 

BRIJESH KUMAR GUPTA

VERSUS

NARCOTICS CONTROL BUREAU

NDPS ACT

V.K. JAIN,J

3RD

CO.APPL.2091/2013 AND 2259/2013 IN CO.PET. 558/2012

CITIBANK, N.A.

VERSUS

MOSER BAER INDIA LTD

COMPANIES ACT

R.V.EASWAR,J

3RD

CRL.A. 1503/2011

 

ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE

VERSUS

MORGAN INDUSTRIES LTD

FOREIGN EXCHANGE REGULATION ACT, 1973

S.P.GARG,J

3RD

CRL. A. 807/2010

 

GIANSHREE

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G.P. MITTAL,J

3RD

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 517/1999

GURDEEP SINGH

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G.P. MITTAL,J

 

3RD

CRL. A.197 of 2010

 

MOHD. AKHTAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

V.K. JAIN,J

3RD

MAC.APP. No.286/2014

 

NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD

VERSUS

YASMIN

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

3RD

MAC.APP.565/2011

 

NATIOINAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD

VERSUS

SHRI NAND LAL

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

3RD

MAC.APP.247/2011

 

NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO LTD

VERSUS

ROSHINI MAMGAI & ORS

CODE OF CIVIL  PROCEDURE

SURESH KAIT,J

3RD

Crl. Appeal No. 7/2014

 

NIPUN GOLA @ NIKHIL

VERSUS

STATE

CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G. P. MITTAL,J

 

3RD

W.P.(C) 1225/2014

 

PRAMOD ARORA

VERSUS

HON’BLE LT. GOVERNOR OF DELHI

DELHI SCHOOL EDUCATION ACT, 1973

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

 

3RD

CRL. A. 752/2010

 

RAJBIR SINGH

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

V.K. JAIN,J

3RD

CRL.A. 249/2006

 

RAJU

VERSUS

STATE OF NCT OF DELHI

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

 

3RD

CRL.A.843/2012

 

ROHIT

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

 

S.P.GARG,J

3RD

CS(OS) No.2695/2011

 

SATYA GUPTA

VERSUS

GUNEET SINGH

SUIT FOR PARTITION

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

3RD

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 476/1998

SHANKAR LAL@SHANKAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G.P. MITTAL,J

 

3RD

CRL.A. 659/2012

 

VIKAS @ JOHNY

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

3RD

CRL.A. 166/2012

 

VIPIN

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

4TH

RSA No. 97/2014

AFROZ JAHAN

VERSUS

S.A. NAQVI

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

4TH

RSA No. 246/2013 & CM Nos. 17415/2013 & CM No.17416/2013

BHAJAN LAL

VERSUS

JIVAN KISHORE

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

4TH

CRL. A.1021 of 2013

 

JAGIRO

VERSUS

STATE

NDPS ACT

V.K. JAIN,J

4TH

CRL.A.No. 555/2012

MUNIR @ CHOTA

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

4TH

CRL. A.38 of 2010

SHEIKH HUSSAIN @ GATKU

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

V.K. JAIN,J

4TH

FAO No. 380/2013

 

UNION OF INDIA

VERSUS

LEELA DEVI & ORS.

RAILWAY CLAIMS TRIBUNAL ACT, 1987

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

4TH

MAC.APP. No.901/2012

 

VINOD CHAUDHARY

VERSUS

RATTAN SINGH & ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

10TH

FAO No.367/2013

 

UNION OF INDIA

VERSUS

JAIN STEEL INDUSTRIES & ORS.     

ARBITRATION & CONCILIATION ACT, 1996

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

15TH

FAO No. 97/2012

 

UNION OF INDIA

VERSUS

DURGA DEVI & ORS

RAILWAY CLAIMS TRIBUNAL ACT

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

15TH

CRL.A. 1440/2011

 

SACHIN KUMAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

 

15TH

MAC.APP.No.1131/2011

 

SH. RAMESH CHAND PASI & ORS.

VERSUS

SUKAN MEHTO & ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

 

SURESH KAIT,J

15TH

FAO No. 365/2012

 

RAHUL TYAGI

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN SUCCESSION ACT, 1925

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

15TH

FAO No. 50/2012 & CM No. 1773/2012 (Stay)

 

ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.

VERSUS

PALWINDER KAUR & ORS

EMPLOYEE’S COMPENSATION ACT

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

15TH

MAC.APP.No.377/2013

 

NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO LTD.

VERSUS

PHOOLO DEVI & ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

15TH

RSA No.100/2014

 

NARESH KUMAR CHOPRA

VERSUS

SUNITA KHANNA AND ANR

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

15TH

W.P.(C) 1451/2013

 

OMAXE LTD. AND ANR.

VERSUS

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX AND ANR

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

 

16TH

MAC.APP.No.1113/2011

 

TEJPAL         

VERSUS

DEEPAK  & ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

 

SURESH KAIT,J

 

16TH

FAO No. 108/2014

 

SUBRATO CHAUDHARY

VERSUS

DINESH KUMAR

EMPLOYEE’S COMPENSATION ACT

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

16TH

CRL.A. 209/2011

 

SHER MOHAMMAD @ SHERA

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

16TH

MAC.APP.No.597/2012

 

ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD

VERSUS

RITU KAPOOR & ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

16TH

MAC.APP. 1101/2011

 

NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO LTD.

VERSUS

SUNITA & ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

16TH

CRL.A. 1047/2012

 

NARESH KUMAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

16TH

RSA No. 211/2013 & CM No. 14337/2013 (stay)

MINU SHARMA

VERSUS

NEELAM VARSHNEY

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

 

16TH

REV. PET. NO. 45/2012

 

ANUJ SHARMA

VERSUS

AHSAHUL HAQ & ORS

MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

SURESH KAIT,J

16TH

CS(OS) 2940/2011 & IA No.18865/2011

B.T.M EXPORTS LTD

VERSUS

ADHUNIK CORPORATION LTD.                  

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

16TH

ITA 511/2013

 

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE – II

VERSUS

ANKIT GARMENTS MANUFACTURING CO

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J        

 

16TH

ITA 180/2013

 

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-II

VERSUS

ASHOK WADIA

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

 

16TH

ITAs 1102/2011 & 1103/2011,ITA 1102/2011

 

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-IV

VERSUS

DEVASAN INVESTMENT PVT. LTD

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J        

 

16th

FAO No. 177/2012 & CM No. 7366/2012

 

EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE CORP. & ANR

VERSUS

POONAM SHARMA & ORS.    

EMPLOYEES’ STATE INSURANCE ACT, 1948

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

16TH

ITA 507/2013

 

NTPC LTD

VERSUS

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-V

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

 

16TH

CUSAA 3/2014 & C.M. No.829/2014

 

SONY INDIA PVT. LTD

VERSUS

THE COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS, NEW DELHI 

CUSTOMS ACT, 1962

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

17TH

RSA No. 79/2014 & CM No. 4737/2014

 

SHRI NATH CARGO PVT. LTD.

VERSUS

PARAG SAREES

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

 

17TH

MAC.APP. No.912/2011

 

RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO

VERSUS

GULABI DEVI & ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

 

17TH

MAC.APP.No. 2/2013

 

PARVESH

VERSUS

DHARMENDER & ORS

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

17TH

CRL.A. 233/2006

 

PANKAJ KUMAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

 

17TH

MAC.APP. No.966/2011

 

ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD

VERSUS

VIKRAM @ SANJAY

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

 

17TH

MAC.APP.No.1169/2011

 

NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO LTD

VERSUS

VIMLESH & ORS.      

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

17TH

RSA 183/2012 & CM 19735/2012

ANJU BALA ETC.

VERSUS

MEERA SAXENA

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

 

17TH

RSA Nos.65/1997, 66/1997, 67/1997, 68/1997 & 69/1997

CHANDER LAL VIRMANI

VERSUS

RAM PIARI     

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

17TH

CRL.L.P. 352/2012

 

STATE

VERSUS

JEEWAN KUMAR PASWAN & ORS

CODE OF CRIMINAL  PROCEDURE

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G.P. MITTAL,J

 

21ST

ITA 561/2012

 

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-IV

VERSUS

D&M COMPONENTS LTD.     

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

 

21ST

CO.APP. 22/2014

 

M-TECH DEVELOPERS LTD.  

VERSUS

SWAPNA BHATTACHARYA

COMPANIES ACT, 1956

REVA KHETRAPAL,J

PRATIBHA RANI,J

 

21ST

CRL.A. No. 1192/2012

 

NEERAJ         

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

MUKTA GUPTA,J

 

21ST

MAC.APP. No.352/2014

 

RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY

VERSUS

KUSUM & ORS.

COMPENSATION MATTER

SURESH KAIT,J

22ND

CS(OS) 1306/2005

AKBAR ALI

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

22ND

CMI No.3/2013

 

CA NANDLAL KEDIA

VERSUS

LT. GOVERNOR AND ORS

DELHI POLICE ACT, 1978

VALMIKI J.MEHTA,J

22ND

CO.APP. 73/2013

 

 

RAVI KUMAR

VERSUS

THE OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR & ANR

COMPANIES ACT, 1956

SANJIV KHANNA,J

G.P. MITTAL,J

 

22ND

I.A. No. 16744/2011 in CS (OS) 1544/2011

 

VANDANA SHARMA   

VERSUS

HEMLATA GOSWAMY & ANR.

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

MUKTA GUPTA,J

 

23RD

CRL.A. 361/2012 & CRL.M.B.No. 343/2014

ANIL   

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

23RD

CRL.A. 39/2014 & CRL.M.B.No. 70/2014

 

MOHD. YUSUF  @ CHUMMA

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

23RD

CRL.A. No. 670/2002 & Crl. M.A. No.2787/2003

 

RANJEET MALIK

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

23RD

CS(OS) 1412/2012

 

SHAIVAL SAHAY

VERSUS

GOVIND VERMA & ORS

CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

23RD

CS(OS) 1854/2011

 

SHIKHA MISRA & ANR

VERSUS

S. KRISHNAMURTHY

SUIT FOR SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

23RD

CS(OS) 2293/2013

 

UNISTRAW HOLDINGS PTE LTD

VERSUS

NITIN AGARWAL & ANR

SUIT FOR PERMANENT INJUNCTION

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

24TH

W.P.(C) 337/2014

 

ASHOK KUMAR AHLUWALIA

VERSUS

THE CHAIMAN & MANAGING DIRECTOR

NATIONAL FERTILIZERS LIMITED

SERVICE MATTER

RAJIV SHAKDHER,J

24TH

CRL.A. 974/2011

 

CHANDAN @ BABAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

24TH

CRL.A. 1308/2011 & CRL.M.B.No. 626/2014

 

RAJ KUMAR

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

24TH

CRL.A. No. 272/2003

 

RAM PRABHU SHARMA

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J

24TH

CRL.A. 1168/2012 & CRL.M.A.No. 17574/2012

VIMLESH

VERSUS

BSES RAJDHANI POWER LTD

ELECTRICITY ACT

S.P.GARG,J

 

25TH

W.P.(C) No.6807/2012

 

CENTRICA INDIA OFFSHORE PVTL. LTD.         

VERSUS

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME

INDIAN INCOME TAX ACT, 1961

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

 

25TH

ITA 176/2014

 

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DELHI –I

VERSUS

AGILE PROPERTIES PVT.LTD.

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

25TH

CRL.A. 515/2011 & CRL.M.B.No. 562/2014

 

MAQSOOD AHMED

VERSUS

THE STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

25TH

CRL.A. 372/2011 & Crl.M.B.No.599/2014

 

NASIRUDDIN @ GUDDU

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

S.P.GARG,J

25TH

ITA No.485/2012

 

RADIALS INTERNATIONAL

VERSUS

ASSTT. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX         

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

 

25TH

W.P.(C) 3891/2013

 

 

SAMSUNG INDIA ELECTRONICS PVT. LTD

VERSUS

DY DIRECTOR OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE-2(2)

INCOME TAX ACT

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

R.V. EASWAR,J

 

25TH

CS(OS) 585/2012

 

SHASHI GARG

VERSUS

SHITIZ METALS LTD

SUIT FOR RECOVERY

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW,J

25TH

CRL.A. 154/2006

 

SOHAN LAL   

VERSUS

STATE

INDIAN PENAL CODE

INDERMEET KAUR,J